Police Mistakes Lead to Tragic Jail Death and Lawsuit Settlement

A recent lawsuit against Williamson County has ended with a $1.25 million settlement. The case involved the death of Joshua McNatt, a 37-year-old man who died by suicide while in jail. This sad event shows how police and jail staff can make serious mistakes that hurt people.

When McNatt was arrested in 2021, he told jail staff he was suicidal. He also had mental health problems like schizophrenia, anxiety, and depression. Even though the jail knew about his issues, they didn’t give him his mental health medicines.

The biggest mistake happened when McNatt was on suicide watch. A jail officer gave him towels, a sheet, and a blanket. These items can be dangerous for someone who might try to hurt themselves. Just 18 minutes later, officers found McNatt hanging in his cell.

The lawsuit said the jail broke many rules by leaving a suicidal person with things he could use to harm himself. After McNatt was taken to the hospital, the jail released him from custody. The lawsuit claims this was done to avoid paying his medical bills.

Sadly, this isn’t the only case like this in Williamson County. The county has paid millions of dollars to settle other lawsuits about inmates dying in jail. In one case, a suicidal inmate was given a bed sheet and used it to try to kill himself. In another, a mentally ill inmate died after being denied medical help.

These cases show how important it is for police and jail staff to take mental health seriously and follow proper safety rules. When they don’t, people can get hurt or even die. If you or someone you know has been mistreated by police or in jail, it’s important to speak up and seek help from a lawyer who understands these issues.

What Our Clients Say

I have dealt with some shady personal injury attorneys in years past.  Andrew came referred to me by a mutual friend.  A native Spanish-speaking friend of mine was in an accident and couldn't advocate for herself because of the language barrier. She cannot thank me enough for introducing her to Andrew and his team every time I see her.  He has been there to help her through issues with her injuries, doctors and clinics.  He is an honest man that isn't just interested in settling a case, he wants to make sure that his clients are able to get their lives back in order after an accident.  I would definitely recommend Andrew and the Traub Law office to anyone that needs help navigating the world after an accident.

5/ 5
Carrie S.

Contact Us

Please let us know what's on your mind. Have a question for us? Ask away.
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Some of our Awards

Super Lawyers Top One Percent Lawyers of Distinction Million Dollar Advocates Forum National Trial Lawyers Top 100 Avvo 10/10 rating Top 100 Verdict


8701 Shoal Creek Boulevard, Suite 401, Austin, TX 78757
Get Directions


Office: 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. Monday through Friday

Appointments available: All days and hours.

Phones answered 24/7


5.0 / 5 over 38 reviews

See Reviews

Leave a Review



While most of our clients hail from Austin, Round Rock, Cedar Park, Georgetown, and Pflugerville in Travis and Williamson Counties, we have also worked with clients in Dallas, Houston, and San Antonio. Other clients have come from Lakeway, Jollyville, Anderson Mill, Kyle, and Leander. If your accident was in Texas, we can help you. The information on this website is for general information purposes only. Nothing on this site should be taken as legal advice for any individual case or situation. This information is not intended to create, and receipt or viewing does not constitute, an attorney-client relationship.
Back To Top