Traub law office logo image

How is Negligence Determined Legally?

Negligence, a pivotal concept in legal proceedings involving accidents and injuries, is often at the core of determining fault and liability. It is generally defined as a failure to employ “ordinary care”, meaning not acting as a person of ordinary prudence would under similar circumstances, or taking actions that such a person would avoid.

Defining and Identifying Negligence

In simpler terms, negligence involves conduct that falls beneath legally established standards meant to safeguard others from unreasonable risk of harm. A person is deemed to have acted negligently if their actions diverge from what is expected of a reasonably prudent individual in analogous situations. Demonstrating this in a legal context often involves navigating through complex legalese, which can potentially be exploited by defense lawyers, especially when plaintiffs are tasked with substantiating that the defendant wasn’t exercising ordinary care.

Core Components and Scenarios in Negligence Cases

To establish negligence as a cause for legal action, a plaintiff must ascertain the following:

  1. The defendant owed a duty to the plaintiff.
  2. There was a breach of that duty by the defendant failing to adhere to the expected standard of conduct.
  3. The defendant’s negligent conduct was causally linked to harm to the plaintiff.
  4. The plaintiff incurred actual harm or damage.
Practical Tip

Question to ask the insurance adjuster: Shouldn’t I wait to settle the claim until my medical treatment concludes or until I’m sure that I have made a full recovery?

Andrew Traub

In the realm of vehicular accidents, several scenarios can emerge where determining negligence becomes intricate. For instance, if a person hits your car due to a sudden emergency, like avoiding a head-on collision, or experiences a health emergency like a heart attack, they might not be deemed negligent. Various defenses, such as the “sneeze defense”, where a driver unintentionally accelerates due to a sneeze, have been utilized and won in cases, underscoring the sometimes-blurred lines of defining negligence.

Defenses and Varied Forms of Negligence

Some defenses to negligence include Contributory Negligence, where the plaintiff contributes to their own injuries or fails to safeguard themselves from foreseeable risks. In some contexts, it’s crucial to establish “gross negligence” – a more egregious form of negligence characterized by recklessness and a substantial lack of concern for whether an injury results, like driving under the influence, as opposed to “ordinary negligence”.

Legal Assistance in Negligence Cases

Navigating through negligence claims can be intricate and challenging, especially given that various defenses and complex scenarios can muddy the waters. Whether it’s proving the negligent party was indeed at fault or substantiating your damages, each phase requires strategic legal actions.

If you’ve been injured in an accident and are entangled in the complexities of establishing negligence, reach out to us at (512) 246-9191 or connect with us online. Our skilled lawyers are here to assist you in recovering medical expenses, lost wages, and compensation for pain and suffering, ensuring you navigate through the legal pathways with adept guidance and support.

Tags:
Back To Top